Chekhov himself was infuriated by the Comparing tolstoy and chekov essays, charging that director Konstantin Stanislavsky had ruined the play. Tolstoy, through his character, Levin, in Anna Kareninaasked what the meaning of life is. Carol ApollonioProfessor of the Practice of Russian, Duke University The question shot straight into my brain and disabled the parietal cortex.
Both Dostoevsky and Tolstoy write in a way that conveys the energy of life. The commandment against lust eventually led him to propose in his afterword to Kreytserova sonata [; The Kreutzer Sonata], a dark novella about a man who murders his wife total abstinence as an ideal.
Despite frequent resolutions to change his ways, he continued his loose life during stays in Tula, Moscow, and St.
I was lucky enough to be, at the time, very young, very curious and seriously uninformed. Dostoevsky digs deeply into the individual human psyche.
Sonya jumps up, looks at him and trembles. In his writings illness often brings insight, while Tolstoy mostly though not always prefers healthy states to unhealthy ones. For both feelings trump reason in the soul, though Tolstoy is closer to the Greeks and the Enlightenment in his association of virtue with reason.
Despite her continuing feelings for Trigorin, she leaves the estate to accept a position with a mediocre theatrical company in a small town. She at last commits suicide by throwing herself under a train.
Many years and many books later, the two authors continue to inhabit different places in my mind and in my memory. The sets, the lighting, the sound effects, and the acting all emphasized elements of tragedy in a play that Chekhov vehemently insisted was a comedy.
This implies that there is a winner and a loser. Everyone feels regret or guilt, and there is no escaping the agony of choice. Interested in literature and ethicshe was drawn to the works of the English novelists Laurence Sterne and Charles Dickens and, especially, to the writings of the French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau ; in place of a cross, he wore a medallion with a portrait of Rousseau.
Nina had become pregnant but lost the baby after being abandoned by Trigorin; she is now pursuing her acting career in various provincial towns.
Legacy In contrast to other psychological writers, such as Dostoyevsky, who specialized in unconscious processes, Tolstoy described conscious mental life with unparalleled mastery.
My own sympathies are with Tolstoy, and even my criteria for judging a work of fiction, I admit, are relentlessly Tolstoyan. In the first scene, Kitty and Anna are sitting on a sofa. From my point of view at least, they are both great writers and now live in a realm beyond competition.
Which is better, the sky or the grass, night or day? Both associate the self with moral agency; for both therefore, the individual is the ultimate source of good and evil. Each of the two writers describes crises in faith.
In brief, Tolstoy rejected all the sacraments, all miracles, the Holy Trinity, the immortality of the soul, and many other tenets of traditional religion, all of which he regarded as obfuscations of the true Christian message contained, especially, in the Sermon on the Mount.
Then, after an interlude during which he considered writing a novel about Peter the Great and briefly returned to pedagogy bringing out reading primers that were widely usedTolstoy wrote his other great novel, Anna Karenina.
His protagonists are shown in extreme situations, where not only their personality but their very nature is put to the test. Tolstoy gravitated in old age toward Christian anarchy, while Dostoevsky in his last novel Brothers Karamazov seems to advocate for a Christian theocracy headed by someone like Zosima.
Chris Huntingtonauthor of the novel Mike Tyson Slept Here Reading Tolstoy transports me to another world; reading Dostoevsky makes me feel alive in this one.
For Dostoevsky, reason is always tainted by egotism, and therefore he relies on love to spur moral impulses. Compare fleshy old Fyodor Karamazov with his ethereal son Alyosha. The intellect sends forth an unending flow of words.
At last he learns that not he but she is the saint, that sainthood cannot be achieved by imitating a model, and that true saints are ordinary people unaware of their own prosaic goodness. After his return to Russia, he decided that his real vocation was pedagogyand so he organized a school for peasant children on his estate.
However, it is the present that concerns Chekhov most. Probably even more than Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy has been praised as being the greatest novelist in world literature.
As the novel progresses, Anna, who suffers pangs of conscience for abandoning her husband and child, develops a habit of lying to herself until she reaches a state of near madness and total separation from reality.
Later on, I lost her.Tolstoy or Dostoevsky? 8 Experts on Who’s Greater. Lists Notable Articles.
Kevin Hartnett April 23, is that Tolstoy was a rural writer and Dosteyevsky an urban one. That is basic oversimplification but works for me. Now Chekov.I love! But Dosteyevsky’s judge who could not come up for the word banana is my hero!
Comparing Tolstoy. Essays and criticism on Anton Chekhov's The Seagull - Thomas G. Winner (essay date February ) The Seagull, Anton Chekhov - Essay Anton Chekhov.
Why is Chekov's "The Seagull" considered. Leo Tolstoy: Leo Tolstoy, Russian author, a master of realistic fiction and one of the world’s greatest novelists. Tolstoy is best known for his two longest works, War and Peace (–69) and Anna Karenina (–77), which are commonly regarded as among the finest novels ever written.
War and Peace in.
Comparing Maupassant's Necklace and Chekov's Vanka - Narrators and Sympathy in Maupassant's Necklace and Chekov's Vanka In Guy de "The Necklace" and Anton Chekov's "Vanka," the narrators' attitudes are unsympathetic toward the protagonists Mathilde and Vanka.
Essays - largest database Tolstoy, and Anton Chekhov give Comparing Works of Art 1 COMPARING WORKS OF ART Comparing Works of Art American Intercontinental University Comparing Works of Art 2 Table of Contents Page 3.
Abstract Page 4. Art Terms of the Renaissance Page 5. Michelangelo Buonarroti and Leonardo da Vinci. Free leo tolstoy papers, essays, and research papers.Download